Long overdue update!
We had the same renters since the day we signed that first contract. Just over 6 years they were here. No real problems over the years but a couple checks that didn't clear but they paid cash within a couple days to square up. They had the opportunity to rent-to-own somewhere closer to work, so I let them get out of our rental contract at the beginning of December 2019. The house wasn't trashed or damaged but there was a truck load of trash left behind.
We put the house up for sale right away in December to see what the market was like. Started in the high $80k's and over the course of 4 months we dropped the price to low 80's and had NO offers. A few dozen showings but no offer on paper. Less than a week before we had a new renter lined up to move in, we finally got an offer! Cash, no contingencies, as-is, close in 2 weeks! We did the final paperwork last Friday and are now out of the income property game.
This was a great learning experience. Really, no problems to speak of regarding the tennants. We sold for double the purchase price and have not spent more than $1,500 on repairs since the original work we did to the house. With Covid taking over, we thought there wouldn't be a buyer at this time. Renters are OK and we would have done it again, but having this money available has got us into a situation where we can refinance our primary home from the 30yr mortgage @ 4% to a 15yr mortgage @ 2.625%. That will save us over $140k in interest.
https://www.zillow.com/homes/105-W-Cherry-St-Fox-Lake,-WI,-53933_rb/40255143_zpid/