I've been busy but found/noticed the speed problem with the other player.
Something so stupid and simple that I completely overlooked it.
These pinch rollers aren't really held in with anything.
I noticed the right one was tipped and falling off of it's post so the tape was just being pulled through by the take up reel.
Apparently when I removed them to replace the diode, I pushed the left pinch roller back on without realizing it which is why it suddenly started to work correctly.
I picked it up and slid it on the post and now they're both working correctly.
Now I'm having a problem with the 3.5mm headphone jack on the back of the board.
I worked it with some cleaner and the right side stopped working unless I play with the plug in the jack.
I already had it apart and cleaned the contacts and assumed it was ok but it's not.
It looks similar to an Alps push button switch.
When you insert a plug, it moves the contacts from one side to the other.
Apparently there is something that I missed in the body of the jack.
I'll have to take it back apart and see what I can find.