ClaretBadger said:
One thing to note about Naks
They're great decks - the best in fact
BUT
Their tapes only really sound good on other Naks
Sorry, but I gotta disagree. Are you saying that because that is your experience, or because that is what you heard?
That is more of an audio urban legend than it is fact. But, it is a surprisingly common comment about Naks and I wonder where that came from because that has not been my experience at all. My theory is that, being among the very best tape deck makers, Nakamichi always have that proverbial target on their chest. I think this train of thought came from audio salesmen who didn't have Naks to sell, when they were trying to hock other decks they had on hand instead. Hey, it does "sound" plausible.. Especially when you're trying to justify why you are buying a lesser product.
I am also an active member of tapeheads.net and this topic came up there and was thoroughly discussed a while back. The large majority of folks who engaged in that discussion felt pretty much the same way I do on this topic.
Playback variance from one deck to another is actually quite common, due mostly to slight alignment differences (azimuth, tilt, head height, etc..) from one unit to the next. Doesn't matter if the original machine was a Denon, a Teac or a Nak. If the "other" machine doesn't read the tape properly, it will sound lifeless and flat, or worse even....
I think the key is to have a PROPERLY set up deck for on which to record, and use tapes that you know work good in that machine. I have four Naks here, all of which I've used for recording, and I've played those tapes in a huge variety of other MFR cassette decks (Onkyo, Denon, Pioneer, Aiwa, Akai, Tascam, etc...) and they've sounded excellent.
In fact, I gave out over 20 nak-recorded tapes at the meet earlier this month... So, I ask that any of you who got one of those tapes from me to please chime in here and share your experience. Grab that tape (or tapes) and give a real good listen on your best boomer or non-Nak component deck. Use headphones if you have them... And then, if you have a Nak, listen to it on that deck , too... does it sound better in the Nak? Please share your thoughts regarding the sound quality of the recording. I'd be real curious to hear if you think the tapes sounded flat, or if they were rich and vibrant...
I'm not trying to start a fight, just looking for some feedback to see if there really is any truth to this "nak recorded tapes only sound good in naks" comment. And since I handed out so many tapes that I KNOW came from properly working decks, this would be useful exercise to help further dispell or maybe even substantiate this debate...
ClaretBadger - I'd also be willing to engage in a one-on-one tape trade with you... I'll send you one of my Nak tapes so you can hear how it sounds in your Kenwoods. And I would be very interested in hearing what your Kenwood made tapes sound like in my Naks. I've always thought of Kenwood as a very good amplifier, EQ and tuner company, moreso than any of their other components.
L8R,
JT